Download full text

Illumination of Historical Monuments in Rural Landscapes: Differences in Approaches, Technological Solutions, and Observer Perception

Abstract: Recent advances in lighting technologies are reshaping the nocturnal environment and the ways in which historical monuments are presented within the landscape. This study examines how lighting conditions that are positively perceived at close range can be transferred to the illumination of historical monuments situated in predominantly dark rural landscapes. Attention is given to the relationship between the visual presentation of cultural heritage, the preservation of landscape character, and the environmental impacts of artificial light at night (ALAN). The research forms part of a broader sequence of experiments investigating observer preferences for architectural lighting with systematically varied luminance levels and spectral compositions. Findings from a previous laboratory were first examined in an outdoor close-range setting, where the illuminated surface occupied a substantial part of the observer’s visual field. The resulting optimized lighting scenarios were subsequently applied to experimental lighting installations in rural landscapes, where the illuminated monument formed only a small part of a predominantly dark visual scene. All installations were assessed through field measurements and subjective evaluation, combining a pilot assessment at close range with qualitative observations from medium- and long-distance viewpoints. The study investigated how correlated colour temperature (CCT), luminance, observation distance, visual adaptation and antecedent lighting conditions interact with landscape context, atmospheric conditions and natural sources of nocturnal illumination. Results indicate that increasing luminance does not necessarily improve the perceived visual quality of architectural lighting. Very warm light (CCT ≤ 2200 K), associated with reduced impacts on the nocturnal environment, was generally well accepted and perceived as pleasant and consistent with the character of the sites. Conversely, light with a CCT 3000 K, commonly described in lighting practice as warm white, was perceived under night-time conditions as neutral white and less appealing in the historical context. With increasing observation distance, differences between the tested very warm lighting scenarios became progressively less important, while the influence of landscape context and prevailing atmospheric conditions increased. The findings demonstrate that context-sensitive lighting design can balance cultural heritage presentation, landscape character and nocturnal environmental protection. Very warm light sources combined with low luminance levels achieve this balance without compromising the perceived visual quality of illuminated historical monuments in rural landscapes.

HADRAVOVÁ, Věra, KUČERA, Patrik, KÁRNÍKOVÁ, Hana, HAVLÍK, Jan, MAIEROVÁ, Lenka (2025). Osvětlení historických objektů v krajině: rozdíly v přístupech, technologické možnosti a vnímání pozorovatelem. In: Jiří Kugl, ed. Člověk, stavba a územní plánování 19. ČVUT v Praze, Fakulta stavební pp. 312-332. ISBN 978-80-01-07579-1. ISSN 2336-7695.